Opinion: No Labels, No Chance: Why a Centrist Third Party Is Doomed to Fail
Arnold Jones
The No Labels group, a self-proclaimed bipartisan organization that claims to represent the "sensible center" of American politics, has recently released a policy document that outlines its vision for the country and its potential presidential bid in 2024. The group, which boasts some prominent members such as former governors John Kasich and Christine Todd Whitman, former senators Joe Lieberman and Evan Bayh, and billionaire businessman Howard Schultz, hopes to appeal to the millions of voters who are dissatisfied with both major parties and their polarizing candidates.
But the No Labels group is delusional if it thinks it has any chance of winning the White House or even making a dent in the electoral map. The group is wasting its time and money on a hopeless endeavor that will only serve to help the Democrats and their radical agenda. Here are some reasons why:
- The No Labels group has no clear identity or message. The group's policy document is a vague and bland collection of platitudes and buzzwords that tries to please everyone but ends up pleasing no one. The group claims to support "common sense solutions" and "pragmatic leadership", but what does that even mean? How does the group plan to address the most pressing issues facing the country, such as immigration, health care, national security, and the economy? The group offers no specifics or details, only generalities and clichés. The group's name itself is a contradiction: how can it have no labels when it clearly labels itself as centrist?
- The No Labels group has no base or constituency. The group assumes that there is a large and untapped market for centrist politics in America, but this is a myth. The reality is that most Americans identify with either the Republican or the Democratic party, and even those who are independent tend to lean toward one side or the other. The group also ignores the fact that the political landscape has shifted dramatically in recent years, with both parties becoming more ideologically coherent and cohesive. The group's attempt to appeal to the mythical "moderate middle" is doomed to fail, because there is no such thing.
- The No Labels group has no charisma or credibility. The group's leaders and potential candidates are either has-beens or never-weres, who have little name recognition or popularity among the voters. They are either failed politicians who have been rejected by their own parties, such as Kasich and Lieberman, or wealthy elites who have no connection or appeal to the ordinary people, such as Schultz and Whitman. They are neither inspiring nor trustworthy, and they have no track record of success or accomplishment. They are simply opportunists who are trying to exploit the public's frustration with the status quo.
- The No Labels group has no strategy or viability. The group's plan to run a third-party candidate in 2024 is a pipe dream that will only backfire. The group faces insurmountable obstacles in getting on the ballot in all 50 states, raising enough funds to compete with the major parties, attracting enough media attention and public support, and overcoming the winner-take-all system that favors the two-party duopoly. The group's best-case scenario is to play spoiler and siphon off enough votes from one of the major candidates to tip the balance in favor of the other. But this is more likely to hurt the Republicans than the Democrats, since most of the group's supporters are likely to come from the center-right rather than the center-left. The group's worst-case scenario is to be ignored and irrelevant, which is what will probably happen.
The No Labels group is a fool's errand that will only benefit the Democrats and their socialist agenda. The group should disband and stop wasting its resources on a futile project that will only harm the country. The only way to stop the Democrats and their radical policies is to unite behind President Trump and his America First platform. Trump is the true leader of the sensible center, who represents the interests and values of millions of patriotic Americans who love their country and want to make it great again.
Additional reading:
